AbstractBrazil is the world's largest coffee producer. Brown eye spot (BES) (Cercospora coffeicola) is a major crop disease that can cause 15–30% production losses and decrease the coffee beverage quality. Although the influence of this disease on beverage quality has been studied, diagrammatic scales for assessment of the disease severity in berries are still unexplored. Thus, this study has developed and validated diagrammatic scales to assess the severity of BES. Two diagrammatic scales were designed to assess the disease in berries, which can be yellow or red depending on the cultivar. The scale of yellow berries had nine grades: grade 0: 0%; 1: 0.1–5.0%; 2: 5.1–10.0%; 3: 10.1–15.0%; 4: 15.1–20.0%; 5: 20.1–30.0%; 6: 30.1–40.0%; 7: 40.1–60.0%; and 8: higher than 60.0%, while the scale of red berries had eight grades: grade 0: 0%; 1: 0.1–2.5%; 2: 2.6–5.0%; 3: 5.1–10.0%; 4: 10.1–20.0%; 5: 20.1–30.0%; 6: 30.1–50.0%; and 7: higher than 50.0% severity. Using scales improved accuracy and precision with R2 = 0.99 and provided good repeatability and reproducibility of assessments of disease severity. Both scales can be used because the different berry colour influenced the accuracy and precision between the scales.