Powered by OpenAIRE graph
Found an issue? Give us feedback
image/svg+xml art designer at PLoS, modified by Wikipedia users Nina, Beao, JakobVoss, and AnonMoos Open Access logo, converted into svg, designed by PLoS. This version with transparent background. http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Open_Access_logo_PLoS_white.svg art designer at PLoS, modified by Wikipedia users Nina, Beao, JakobVoss, and AnonMoos http://www.plos.org/ ZENODOarrow_drop_down
image/svg+xml art designer at PLoS, modified by Wikipedia users Nina, Beao, JakobVoss, and AnonMoos Open Access logo, converted into svg, designed by PLoS. This version with transparent background. http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Open_Access_logo_PLoS_white.svg art designer at PLoS, modified by Wikipedia users Nina, Beao, JakobVoss, and AnonMoos http://www.plos.org/
ZENODO
Preprint . 2026
License: CC BY
Data sources: ZENODO
ZENODO
Preprint . 2026
License: CC BY
Data sources: Datacite
ZENODO
Preprint . 2026
License: CC BY
Data sources: Datacite
versions View all 2 versions
addClaim

Not Less, But Other: A Foundational Error in Consciousness Science

Authors: Berkla, D.;

Not Less, But Other: A Foundational Error in Consciousness Science

Abstract

Theories of consciousness routinely identify a structural measure — integrated information, global broadcast, predictive modeling — with consciousness itself. This essay argues the identification is an artifact of a single fact: we have first-person access to exactly one case, our own, where structure and experience coincide, and we read that local coincidence as an identity holding everywhere. The error is shown to operate even in the field's most careful programs, including the author's own published equation. The correction is a single substitution: the structural measure is a necessary condition for phenomenal experience, not the experience itself — a relabeling that asserts nothing about where experience occurs, only that wherever it does, the structure was required. The consequence runs in two directions. The identity over-attributes mind to systems like logic-gate grids, and it under-recognizes mind wherever a system's structure differs from ours, having quietly made our own topology the measure of all cases. The essay states the diagnosis and the correction; the worked demonstration is named as owed, not delivered. June 25, 2026 — Added hyperlinks from in-text citations to reference entries. No changes to text or argument. June 5, 2026 — Restored note on collaborative process inadvertently omitted during compile. Content is otherwise unchanged.

Keywords

consciousness; phenomenal consciousness; hard problem; integrated information theory; global workspace theory; predictive processing; free energy principle; Nagel; anthropocentrism; philosophy of mind

  • BIP!
    Impact byBIP!
    selected citations
    These citations are derived from selected sources.
    This is an alternative to the "Influence" indicator, which also reflects the overall/total impact of an article in the research community at large, based on the underlying citation network (diachronically).
    0
    popularity
    This indicator reflects the "current" impact/attention (the "hype") of an article in the research community at large, based on the underlying citation network.
    Average
    influence
    This indicator reflects the overall/total impact of an article in the research community at large, based on the underlying citation network (diachronically).
    Average
    impulse
    This indicator reflects the initial momentum of an article directly after its publication, based on the underlying citation network.
    Average
Powered by OpenAIRE graph
Found an issue? Give us feedback
selected citations
These citations are derived from selected sources.
This is an alternative to the "Influence" indicator, which also reflects the overall/total impact of an article in the research community at large, based on the underlying citation network (diachronically).
BIP!Citations provided by BIP!
popularity
This indicator reflects the "current" impact/attention (the "hype") of an article in the research community at large, based on the underlying citation network.
BIP!Popularity provided by BIP!
influence
This indicator reflects the overall/total impact of an article in the research community at large, based on the underlying citation network (diachronically).
BIP!Influence provided by BIP!
impulse
This indicator reflects the initial momentum of an article directly after its publication, based on the underlying citation network.
BIP!Impulse provided by BIP!
0
Average
Average
Average