This qualitative study explored the experiences of 26 parents who were involved in surrogate parenting arrangements in a California-based surrogacy program. Participants were mostly white ( n = 23), married ( n = 25), females ( n = 24), with high levels of education and income. The mean age at the time of the first child's birth was 39 yr. ( SD = 5.06). The majority of parents reported having one ( n = 10) or two ( n = 8) children. All subjects reported infertility as their reason to explore surrogacy as a method of building a family. 18 participants chose in vitro fertilization as their method of conception. Telephone interviews explored their decision-making, method of fertilization, their relationship with their surrogate, and the support that they received during the surrogacy process. Results indicate that parents were able to anticipate some potential pitfalls prior to their experience but did not realize the importance of other potential difficulties. A conceptual model is presented with implications for helping professionals.