Sigillins are highly chlorinated natural products from the springtail Ceratophysella sigillata (Collembola) that are used to deter arthropod predators. We report here the isolation and structure elucidation of sigillin F, a hydrogenated benzopyranone compound bearing two trichloromethyl groups, and the synthesis of trideoxysigillin (8), a non-natural compound representing the basic scaffold of the sigillins. Sigillins A and F showed insecticidal activity toward various insects, similar to the commercial insecticide imidacloprid, whereas 8 was inactive. The highest mortality was observed for the aphids Megoura viciae and Myzus persicae, but other insect species were also susceptible. Sigillins act as noncompetitive antagonists of the GABA receptor. This mode of action is identical to that of known insecticides with high chlorine content such as dieldrin or endosulfan. The high content of sigillins in C. sigillata, more than 4 mM in concentration, indicates self-resistance. Strikingly, the Collembola and humans have both arrived at the same target with related types of compounds to combat insects.