Abstract Two different options for the combined recovery of pectin and phenolic compounds from mango peels, a byproduct of industrial mango processing, were developed. After extraction of dried mango peels with diluted sulfuric acid, the phenolic compounds were adsorbed using a styrene–divinylbenzene copolymerisate resin, and pectin was obtained from the effluent by precipitation with ethanol. Phenolic compounds were recovered from the resin with methanol and the eluate was lyophilized (Process I). Alternatively, the pectin was precipitated by adding the crude extract to ethanol. After removal of the organic solvent, the phenolic compounds were obtained from the aqueous phase of the precipitation bath using the adsorbent resin as described before (Process II). While in total, 129.4 mg/g polyphenols were detected in the lyophilizate obtained from Process I, only 71.0 mg/g dm could be recoverd from Process II. The profiles of the polyphenols were almost identical, revealing that during pectin precipitation preferential adsorption of polyphenolic compounds to the pectin may be excluded. Besides the characterization of the pectins and the phenolic compounds, investigations into the influence of the drying temperature on the polyphenolic content of the peels were carried out, indicating a significant loss of flavonol glycosides depending on heat exposure. On the other hand, some xanthone glycosides were formed during the drying process. Furthermore, antioxidative capacities of the lyophilized eluates were investigated using the DPPH, TEAC and FRAP assays. The antioxidative capacity of the extracts exceeded that of mangiferin and quercetin 3-O-glucoside, respectively, thus demonstrating mango peels to be a suitable source of health-beneficial compounds. The lyophilizates obtained from Process I showed higher antioxidative capacities in all three assays. These findings indicate a correlation between the amount of phenolic compounds and the antioxidative capacity. Industrial relevance Byproducts of mango processing amount to 35–60% of the total fruit weight. Their complete exploitation for further product recovery is a promising measure from both an environmental and economic point of view. In our previous study mango peels were found to be a rich source of pectin, with a high degree of esterification and phenolic compounds, like flavonol O- and xanthone C-glycosides. Therefore, two alternative processes for the combined recovery of pectin and polyphenols, which can easily be integrated in an existing pectin production process, were developed in the present study.