Abstract In this study a general methodology employing fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and fuzzy goal programming is developed for selection problems. The proposed methodology has two main sub-phases. In the first phase, fuzzy triangular numbers are used in order to represent the comparisons among decision criteria. Then lower and upper bounds as well as mid-values of priorities belonging to each decision criteria are computed. In the second phase these values and fuzzy triangular numbers are entered into the goal programming model and the model is solved to give the final priorities of decision criteria. Then the weighted sum of ratings for each selection alternative are found where the weights are final priorities from goal programming model. The proposed methodology is presented on a real life roadheader selection problem from mining industry. The results revealed that the methodology is easily applicable and provides satisfactory results.