Abstract This article discusses the development of a Digital Humanities (DH) Association for the UK and Ireland. It explores processes for evidence gathering, methods for building community through consultation, approaches to defining values and purpose through collaboration, and how to practise openness that is both radical and responsible. It begins by outlining the landscape of DH in the UK and Ireland, highlighting differences and similarities between the two countries. Next, it addresses four key areas of focus in the planning for the new Association: community, consultation, and inclusivity; the importance of advocacy for DH and the role of a DH Association in national policy-making; the centrality of training and the development of career pathways in and from DH; and how to go about implementing a values-led organization. Finally, it reflects on the value of international collaboration in the field of DH, both between Ireland and the UK and among international subject associations and infrastructures.