Abstract Background Muscadine grape (Vitis rotundifolia) is resistant to many of the pathogens that negatively impact the production of common grape (V. vinifera), including the bacterial pathogen Xylella fastidiosa subsp. fastidiosa (Xfsf), which causes Pierce’s Disease (PD). Previous studies in common grape have indicated Xfsf delays host immune response with a complex O-chain antigen produced by the wzy gene. Muscadine cultivars range from tolerant to completely resistant to Xfsf, but the mechanism is unknown. Results We assembled and annotated a new, long-read genome assembly for ‘Carlos’, a cultivar of muscadine that exhibits tolerance, to build upon the existing genetic resources available for muscadine. We used these resources to construct an initial pan-genome for three cultivars of muscadine and one cultivar of common grape. This pan-genome contains a total of 34,970 synteny-constrained entries containing genes of similar structure. Comparison of resistance gene content between the ‘Carlos’ and common grape genomes indicates an expansion of resistance (R) genes in ‘Carlos.’ We further identified genes involved in Xfsf response by transcriptome sequencing ‘Carlos’ plants inoculated with Xfsf. We observed 234 differentially expressed genes with functions related to lipid catabolism, oxidation-reduction signaling, and abscisic acid (ABA) signaling as well as seven R genes. Leveraging public data from previous experiments of common grape inoculated with Xfsf, we determined that most differentially expressed genes in the muscadine response were not found in common grape, and three of the R genes identified as differentially expressed in muscadine do not have an ortholog in the common grape genome. Conclusions Our results support the utility of a pan-genome approach to identify candidate genes for traits of interest, particularly disease resistance to Xfsf, within and between muscadine and common grape.