IPBES VA Chapter 6 Text Analysis - Constitutions pluralistic value approach Code: VA_6.1_Ch6 Versioning: 02 (25.09.2020) DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.4329104 Updated Report: 25 September 2020 Project leader(s) Alta de Vos (a.devos@ru.ac.za) Project member(s) Aidin Niamir (CA) (niamir@gmail.com) Eszter Kelemen (kelemen.eszter@essrg.hu) Data curator(s) Gabriela Arroyo (ipbestsuvalues@iies.unam.mx) Description: The IPBES VA mandate for Chapter 6 of the assessment uses the analysis of a Constitutions database to provide insights on the use of plural value approaches within national laws. A text analysis for the Constitutions was designed by identifying the combination of words that provide information towards plural value approaches. Process overview: Protocol: Type of analysis/search/review: Text analysis Search languages: English Search Engine: Constitute Project in: https://www.constituteproject.org/ (Publicly available). Exact Search Date: 8 April 2020 Sample extracted: 202 Constitutions (A) Location and Format of the Data (A): IPBES_VA_6.1_08-04-2020_(A).csv Search terms (R1): TS= ( TITLE-ABS-KEY( ( (world view* OR Weltanschauung OR value* OR pluralistic) AND (valu* OR participat* OR indigenous) AND (knowledge OR endemic) AND (knowledge OR autochthon*) AND (knowledge OR traditional) AND (knowledge OR local) AND (knowledge OR integrat* OR multicriteria OR deliberative) AND (evaluat* OR multiple knowledge OR noesis OR multiple evidence base OR holistic OR trade-off OR tradeoff OR complex OR social-ecological OR human environmental OR socio-ecological OR human-environmental OR rights of rives OR rights of land OR rights to nature OR environmental right* OR instrumental) AND (valu* OR intrinsic) AND (valu* OR relational) AND (valu* OR ecological) AND (valu* OR environment*) AND (valu* OR economic*) AND (valu* OR cultur*) AND (valu* OR sustainable) AND (use OR sustainable) AND (management OR benefit) AND (sharing OR customary OR wonted) Treatment applied: Application of Search terms to constitutions in (A). The manual used to code the constitutions can be found in (R1). A + R1 = B Exact search date: 8 April 2020 Sample extracted: 13121 hits (# of times search terms were found by Country Constitution) (B) Location and Format of the Data (B): IPBES_VA_6.1_08-04-2020_(B).xls (B) Fields extracted (A): ● Country (Country Name), ● Year (the constitution year), ● Order (1 indicates the latest version of the constitution), ● Word, ● Number of occurrence, ● Text (context in which the word is mentioned) Another filter is applied to first search (B) B + R2 = C In the context of (R2): Ecosystems (dictionary), Geographical features (e.g. mountains, rivers, wetlands, oceans, forests, grasslands - as already defined), Nature (dictionary). Treatment applied: Identification of context (R2) in which the bag of words (R1) are found in first search (B). Location and Format of the Data (C): IPBES_VA_6.1_30-06-2020_(C).xls Exact search date: 30 June 2020 Sample extracted: 8692 hits (# of times search terms were found by Country Constitution) (C) Fields extracted (A): ● Country (Country Name)Year (the constitution year) ● Order (1 indicates the latest version of the constitution) ● Word_application (the bag of words (R1) ● Word_context (the bag of words we adapted from the Valuation Uptake) (R2) ● Text (Cells with the paragraph containing the Word_application and/or Word_context). Definition of files ID Name File Type Size A IPBES_VA_6.1_08-04-2020_(A).csv csv B IPBES_VA_6.1_08-04-2020_(B).xls xls C IPBES_VA_6.1_30-06-2020_(C).xls xls R1 IPBES_VA_6.1_08-04-2020_(A)(R1).csv xls R2 IPBES_VA_6.1_08-04-2020_(B)(R2).xls PDF