Artificial Intelligence is no longer a speculative presence in judicial systems. Artificial Intelligence is used for case management software to algorithmic risk assessments used for bail and sentencing decisions across jurisdictions. Courts are increasingly engaging and investing in automated tools that promise efficiency, consistency, and speed. Yet many of these systems still operate as \"black boxes\"—producing outcomes without intelligible explanations. The inclusion of Artificial Intelligence in judicial administration challenges the foundational constitutional question: Can judicial legitimacy survive when reasons are replaced by results? Through an analysis of precedents set by the Supreme Court on reasoned orders and non-arbitrariness, the article…