One of the prominent markers of end-stage heart failure at the molecular level is a decrease in function and/or expression of the sarcoplasmic reticulum ATPase protein [sarco(endo)plasmic reticulum calcium-ATPase, SERCA]. It has been often postulated that a decrease in SERCA pump activity can contribute in a major way to decreased cardiac function. To establish a functional relationship, we assessed how alterations in SERCA activity level affect basic contractile function in healthy myocardium devoid of other significant molecular changes. We investigated baseline contractile function, frequency-dependent activation, and β-adrenergic response in ultrathin trabeculae isolated from hearts of mice overexpressing SERCA (transgenic, TG), underexpressing SERCA2a (heterozygous knockout, Het), and their respective wild-type (WT) littermates. At physiological temperature and frequency, compared with their respective WT littermates, SERCA1a mice displayed increased developed force at frequencies of 4–8 Hz (∼90% increase at 4 Hz) and force equal to WT mice at 10–14 Hz. Force development at 4 Hz in presence of 1 μM isoproterenol was similar in TG and WT mice. In Het mice, developed force was nearly identical at the lower end of the frequency range (4–8 Hz) but slightly depressed at higher frequency ( P < 0.05 at 14 Hz). In presence of 1 μM isoproterenol, developed force at 4 Hz was equal to that in WT mice. Compared with normal levels, increased SERCA activity enhanced force development only at subphysiological frequencies. A reduction in SERCA activity only showed a depression of force at the higher frequency range. Thus generalizations regarding the correlation between SERCA activity and contractility can be highly ambiguous, because this relationship is critically dependent on other factors including stimulation frequency.