The aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AhR) is a nuclear receptor regulating a wide range of biological and toxicological effects. Metabolites of L-tryptophan are able to bind and activate AhR, providing a link between tryptophan catabolism and a novel mechanism of protective tolerance, referred to as "disease tolerance". The notion that pharmacologic modulation of genes associated with endotoxin tolerance would be beneficial in clinical settings dominated by acute hyperinflammatory responses to infection thrusts AhR into the limelight as an interesting druggable target. Combining homology modeling, docking studies, and molecular dynamic simulations with mutagenesis experiments and gene profiling, in this work we report that 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) and two different L-tryptophan metabolites, namely L-Kynurenine and FICZ (6-formylindolo[3,2-b]carbazole), are able to bind to mAhR, exploiting different key interactions with distinct set of fingerprint residues. As a result, they stabilize different conformations of mAhR that, in turn, selectively regulate downstream signaling and transcription of specific target genes. Collectively, these results open new avenues for the design and development of selective AhR modulators that, by targeting specific receptor conformations associated with specific AhR functions, may offer novel therapeutic opportunities in infectious diseases and other morbidity that may be associated with the receptor.