Hereditary non‐polyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC) is caused by inactivating mutations of DNA mismatch repair genes. Large genomic rearrangements in these genes have been increasingly recognized as important causes of HNPCC. Using multiplex ligation‐dependent probe amplification, we identified three MSH2 deletions in Italian patients with HNPCC (proband A: exons 1–3, proband M: exon 8, and proband C: exons 1–6). Deletion breakpoint sequencing allowed us to develop rapid polymerase chain reaction‐based mutation screening, which confirmed the presence of the deletions in affected and asymptomatic individuals of families A, C, and M. While the exon 8 and exon 1–3 deletions appear to be novel, the MSH2 1–6 deletion found in family C is identical to the one recently documented in two branches of another unrelated Italian family (family V+Va). Haplotype analysis showed that the kindreds C and V+Va (both from northeastern Italy, both displaying clinical features of the Muir–Torre syndrome) shared a seven‐locus haplotype, indicating that the MSH2 1–6 deletion is probably a founder mutation. Families A, C, M, and V+Va all showed progressively earlier cancer‐onset ages in successive generations. Analysis of 23 affected parent–child pairs in the four kindreds showed median anticipation of 12 years in offsprings’ onset of cancer (p = 0.0001). No birth cohort effect was found. This is the first significant evidence of anticipation effects in HNPCC families carrying MSH2 deletions.