Progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy (PML) is considered an often fatal, demon-leading disease primarily associated with immunosuppression. Immunocompromised individuals predominantly exhibit this manifestation, while immunocompatible patients rarely encounter it. We present a unique case of PML in an immunocompetent individual who initially presented with stroke-like symptoms, received management, and was subsequently discharged. He returned to our hospital a few days later with similar complaints, prompting further investigations that revealed PML, a condition often overlooked, especially in individuals with an intact immune system. Although he received successful treatment with mefloquine and other anti-malarial medications and followed up on an outpatient basis, his subsequent outcome was unfavourable. As a result, this case emphasises the importance of having PML as a significant differential and therapeutic option.