Peripheral nerve hyperexcitability is an uncommon but treatable condition in neurology. Voltage-gated potassium channelopathies, especially contactin-associated protein-like 2 (CASPR2) antibody, are commonly implicated. We present the case of a 16-year-old boy with tremulousness of both feet and twitching of muscles all over the body for three months. Examination revealed irregular, arrhythmic, small-amplitude twitching movements of the toes along with fasciculations in both thighs. Nerve conduction studies were within normal limits. F-wave studies showed a prolonged polyphasic large-amplitude discharge following the compound muscle action potential and obscuring the F waves. Electromyography showed extensive myokymic discharges. The serum autoimmune antibody profile showed strong positivity for CASPR2. He started lacosamide as a symptomatic treatment. In view of the good symptomatic response, further immunomodulation was deferred and he remains on follow-up. We present this case to highlight the role of motor afterdischarges as a diagnostic clue to peripheral nerve hyperexcitability and to review the literature on this interesting finding.