Neurosarcoidosis (NS) is a mimicker of many infectious, neoplastic, and inflammatory diseases. It most commonly involves the cranial nerves followed by meninges, ventricles, hypothalamic-pituitary axis, spinal cord, and brainstem/cerebellum. While NS myelopathy has been increasingly recognized, pathophysiological/prognostic and management principles in NS-mediated cauda equina (CE) and conus medullaris (CM) syndromes, which constitute a small and rare minority of this subset, remain elusive. We present the case of a 49 -year-old Hispanic man who developed a peripheral facial palsy and primary hypogonadism within a span of 12 months and eventually got diagnosed with NS after he presented with CE syndrome. We also performed an extensive literature review, with a discussion on the underlying pathophysiology and current management recommendations for NS-mediated CE/CM syndrome. CE/CM syndromes in a middle-aged man should prompt the consideration of NS as a possible differential diagnosis. While steroid responsive, the majority of NS-CE/CM patients are left with residual neurodeficits with quick relapses when steroids are tapered, making the case for early institution of immunosuppressive therapies.