Xylooligosaccharides (XOS) have been employed as prebiotics containing oligomers of varying sizes or molecular ratios. XOS with a low degree of polymerization (DP) has been demonstrated to have high prebiotic potential. However, there is limited information regarding the specific chain length of XOS required to elicit distinct responses in the gut microbiota. In this study, we aimed to explore whether variations in XOS DP could alter the fate of colonic fermentation. Five XOS fractions (BWXFs) with DP ranges of >40, 20-40, 10-20, 5-10, and 2-4 were prepared by beechwood xylan autohydrolysis and tested on human gut microbiota. Extracellular XOS degradation was observed for molecules with a DP exceeding 5. BWXF treatments altered the microbial community structures, and substrate size-dependent effects on the microbial composition and metabolic outputs were observed. Bacteroidaceae were specifically enriched by xylan. Lachnospiraceae were particularly stimulated by XOS with a DP of 20-40 and 2-4. Bifidobacteriaceae were notably enriched by XOS with a DP of 5-20. High butyrate yields were obtained from cultures containing long-chain BWXFs. Microbiota responses differed with XOS DP composition changes, and microbial competition with XOS with a DP of 2-4 requires further exploration.