In this paper, I claim that in the context of the constitutional crisis that began in 2015, all main arguments made by the government and supporters of the ruling party in Poland, i.e. Law and Justice (PiS), are bad. First, I propose to go to obvious facts. Secondly, I will separately work on each argument that I think is bad. However, this is interesting that these arguments made by politicians or academic scholars, such as lawyers, sociologists, and philosophers, are in fact fake arguments. They are irrelevant and false. My approach is methodologically holistic (I analysed legal acts, judicial verdicts, political statements, interviews, etc., and I talked to ordinary people). Of my background, I have to make it clear: I am a Polish citizen living abroad and a scholar. I was born and grew up as well as was educated in Poland. Taking a legal-philosophical approach, in this essay I try to explain these diverse constitutional Polish issues in simple words.