We encountered DNA samples which showed a positive product using a long PCR-based method for the detection of CYP2D6*5, indicating deletion of the entire CYP2D6 gene, but the samples did not show a band related to CYP2D6*5 in either XbaI- or EcoRI-RFLP analysis. To achieve genotyping with accuracy, we performed a further genetic analysis to clarify the discrepancy. An unknown 1.6-kb insert was identified in a region downstream from the CYP2D6 stop codon where a specific primer was designed for long-PCR analysis for CYP2D6*5 genotyping. This finding suggested that the CYP2D6 gene might not be deleted in the samples even if a positive product was detected by the long-PCR method. Furthermore, the allelic frequency of this type was found to be approximately 0.3% (4 heterozygous/771 samples) in a Japanese population. In conclusion, we found a novel structure of the CYP2D6 gene, which might lead to incorrect genotyping for CYP2D6*5. Although the long PCR-based strategy for the detection of CYP2D6*5 has been widely used due to its usefulness and convenience, we recommend caution when adopting this method and propose re-evaluating the method for detecting CYP2D6*5.