We report an uncommon case of cholinergic poisoning following an ingestion of wild mushrooms. Two middle-aged patients presented to the emergency unit with acute gastrointestinal symptoms including epigastric pain, vomiting and diarrhea, followed by miosis, palpitations and diaphoresis which were compatible with a cholinergic toxidrome. The patients volunteered a history of taking two tablespoons of cooked wild mushrooms collected in a country park. Mildly elevated liver transaminase was noted in one female patient. Mushroom specimens were sent to a mycologist for identification using morphological analysis. Muscarine, a cholinergic toxin found in mushrooms such as Inocybe and Clitocybe species, was subsequently extracted from and identified in the urine specimens of both patients, using a liquid-chromatography tandem mass spectrometry method. In this report, the variable clinical presentation of cholinergic mushroom poisoning is discussed. Key issues in the management of these cases were presented. In addition to conventional mushroom identification methods, this report also highlights the use of toxicology tests on different biological and non-biological specimens for diagnosis, prognosis and surveillance purposes.