Abstract Target site insensitivity because of mutations in the voltage‐sensitive sodium channel gene ( Vssc ) is a major mechanism of resistance to pyrethroid insecticides in the house fly, Musca domestica . There are three known Vssc alleles that confer resistance to pyrethroids in the house fly: knock down resistance ( kdr ; L1014F), super‐kdr (M918T + L1014F) and kdr‐his (L1014H), but there has been no side‐by‐side comparison of the resistance levels that they confer. We compared the levels of resistance conferred by the three Vssc alleles in congenic strains to 19 structurally diverse pyrethroids, and compared the full‐length Vssc cDNA sequences from each strain. Generally, the levels of resistance conferred were kdr‐his < kdr < super‐kdr . However, there was significant variation in this pattern, especially for super‐kdr , for which both high and low resistance ratios were observed for several pyrethroids. We also examined the levels of resistance in heterozygotes. Resistance in each of the hybrids was generally inherited as an incompletely recessive trait, except for the kdr‐his / kdr hybrids, which showed incompletely to completely dominant resistance (ie had resistance levels comparable to kdr homozygotes). The importance of these results to understanding the frequencies of these resistance alleles in natural populations, the evolution of insecticide resistance and resistance management strategies are discussed.