Abstract Regulated proteolysis of signaling proteins under mechanical tension enables cells to communicate with their environment in a variety of developmental and physiologic contexts. The role of force in inducing proteolytic sensitivity has been explored using magnetic tweezers at the single-molecule level with bead-tethered assays, but such efforts have been limited by challenges in ensuring that beads are not restrained by multiple tethers. Here, we describe a multiplexed assay for single-molecule proteolysis that overcomes the multiple-tether problem using a flow extension (FLEX) strategy on a microscope equipped with magnetic tweezers. Particle tracking and computational sorting of flow-induced displacements allows assignment of tethered substrates into singly-captured and multiply-tethered bins, with the fraction of fully mobile, single-tethered substrates depending inversely on the concentration of substrate loaded on the coverslip. Computational exclusion of multiply-tethered beads enables robust assessment of on-target proteolysis by the highly specific tobacco etch virus protease and the more promiscuous metalloprotease ADAM17. This method should be generally applicable to a wide range of proteases and readily extensible to robust evaluation of proteolytic sensitivity as a function of applied magnetic force.