Abstract The article argues for a sharp analytical distinction between the realms of technology and of law. The question to what extent the law ‘can’ be digitalized relates to technology, whereas the question to what extent it ‘may’ be digitalized falls within the realm of the law. Against this backdrop, it is argued that digital technology does not challenge the law fundamentally. Instead, the crucial questions on the relationship between law and digitalization lie in the details. The article raises those questions and provides an analytical framework for the law of digitalization and the digitalization of law.