One challenge (or opportunity!) that many instructors face is how varied the backgrounds, abilities, and interests of students are. In order to simultaneously instill confidence in those with weaker preparations and still challenge those able to go faster, an instructor must be prepared to give problems of different difficulty levels. Using Dirichlet's Theorem as a case study, we create and discuss a family of problems in number theory that highlight the relative strengths and weaknesses of different ways to approach a question and show how to invite students to extend the problems and explore research-level mathematics.