Strong frequency-dependent selection as found in the self-incompatibility loci of flowering plants maintains allelic lineages for extremely long time scales, such that allelic genealogies can shed insight into long-term demographic patterns of species. Effective mutation rate, as well as demographic change such as population bottlenecks, can influence genealogical structure. In addition, loss of functionality at the self-incompatibility locus is likely to affect radiation rates. Partial sequences for 21 S-RNase alleles of the mid-elevation tropical species Witheringia solanacea were obtained in order to compare their substitution rates and genealogy with those of Witheringia maculata and two species in the closely related genus Physalis. Sequences for W. solanacea fell into the three clades within the Solanaceae already identified for the genus. Terminal branch lengths for W. solanacea, scaled to the total depth of its phylogeny, were intermediate between the unusually short terminal branches of W. maculata and those of the two Physalis species. In contrast to the Physalis species, where interspecific dN/dS for closely related alleles exceeded 1.0 to the same degree as did intraspecific dN/dS, in Witheringia only intraspecific comparisons showed an excess of nonsynonymous substitutions, suggesting postspeciation radiation of alleles. Alleles associated with lowered S-RNase production and self-compatibility showed extremely short terminal branches. In summary, it appears that rapid recent diversification of alleles characterizes the Witheringia lineages. In some cases, this rapid diversification can be attributed to relaxed constraints due to breakdown of self-incompatibility.