Through the syntheses of its C-1 desvinyl, C-7 methylene, C-7 exocyclic ethylidene, and various C-3 phenylmethyl analogues, the structure-activity relationship of antimitotic ottelione A (4) against tubulin and various cancer cells was established. The results indicated that compound 4 was a colchicine-competitive inhibitor and that the C-1 vinyl group is unnecessary for its potency, whereas the C-7 exocyclic double bond is essential, possibly because of its irreversible interaction with tubulin. Further optimization of the substituents on the phenylmethyl group at the C-3 position generated compound 10g with a 3'-fluoro-4'-methoxyphenylmethyl substituent, which was 6-38-fold more active against MCF-7, NCI-H460, and COLO205 cancer cells relative to 4. Results from in vitro tubulin polymerization assay confirmed the potency of compounds 4, 10g, and 11a.