Neoplasms of the tongue are relatively common, and the vast majority are epithelial in phenotype. Although uncommon, a diverse and distinctive array of mesenchymal neoplasms arises in this anatomic site. To increase our understanding of these lesions, we reviewed our experience of MNs of the tongue and described their clinicopathologic features. The pathology archives from 2005 to 2021 and the consultation files of one of the authors were queried for all MNs of the tongue. We reviewed the histologic slides and ancillary studies and obtained clinical data from the available medical records. Ninety-three cases were identified, and they form the study cohort - to our knowledge, this is the largest series of mesenchymal neoplasms of the tongue. Forty-eight patients were female, and forty-five were male, with a mean age of 51 years (range: 1-94 years). The tumors included 43 (46.2%) hemangiomas, 14 (15%) granular cell tumors, 8 (9%) lipomas, 4 (4.3%) schwannomas, 4 (4.3%) solitary fibrous tumors - all with low risk of progression based on risk stratification criteria, 2 (2.2%) lymphangiomas, 3 (3.2%) Kaposi sarcomas, 2 (2.2%) chondromas, 2 (2.2%) myofibromas, 1 (1.1%) solitary circumscribed neuroma, 1 (1.1%) perineurioma, 1 (1.1%) neurofibroma, 1 (1.1%) ectomesenchymal chondromyxoid tumor, 1 (1.1%) atypical glomus tumor with a NOTCH2 rearrangement and TLL2 mutation, 1 (1.1%) spindle cell rhabdomyosarcoma, 1 (1.1%) pleomorphic fibroblastic sarcoma, 1 (1.1%) malignant rhabdoid tumor, 1 (1.1%) leiomyosarcoma, 1 (1.1%) angiosarcoma, and 1 (1.1%) alveolar soft part sarcoma. Most of the patients underwent surgical excision, and 1 patient (with hemangioma) underwent embolization. On follow-up, the patient with spindle cell rhabdomyosarcoma developed postoperative numbness at the surgical site and was disease-free through 17 months of follow-up. The patient with leiomyosarcoma declined adjuvant radiation and developed metastasis to the lung at 22 months. The patient with alveolar soft part sarcoma had metastases to the lung at the time of diagnosis and received adjuvant chemotherapy. The remaining patients had no local or distant recurrence. MNs of the tongue are usually benign and characterized by either endothelial, adipocytic, or schwannian differentiation. The mainstay of treatment is surgical excision with the extent of excision determined by tumor type. Adjuvant therapy is reserved for high-grade sarcomas.