Summary In bacteria, AAA+ proteases such as Lon and ClpXP degrade substrates with exquisite specificity. These machines capture the energy of ATP hydrolysis to power unfolding and degradation of target substrates. Here, we show that a mutation in the ATP binding site of ClpX shifts protease specificity to promote degradation of normally Lon-restricted substrates. However, this ClpX mutant is worse at degrading ClpXP targets, suggesting an optimal balance in substrate preference for a given protease that is surprisingly easy to alter. In vitro , wildtype ClpXP also degrades Lon-restricted substrates more readily when ATP levels are reduced, similar to the shifted specificity of mutant ClpXP, which has altered ATP hydrolysis kinetics. Based on these results, we suggest that rates of ATP hydrolysis not only power substrate unfolding and degradation, but also tune protease specificity. We consider various models for this effect based on emerging structures of AAA+ machines showing conformationally distinct states. Abstract Figure Graphical Abstract eTOC AAA+ proteases, such as Lon and ClpXP, select distinct targets for degradation to maintain proteostasis. Mahmoud et al. show that ATP hydrolysis can tune substrate specificity of ClpX, allowing ClpX to degrade Lon-restricted substrates under limiting ATP conditions or in the presence of a ClpX mutant. Highlights A Walker B mutation of the AAA+ protease ClpX alters substrate specificity ClpX mutant degrades new substrates but degrades canonical substrates less well Decreasing ATP levels enhances ClpXP mediated degradation of some classes of substrates ATP-induced changes in conformational states accompany alterations in ClpX specificity