Chronic contained rupture (CCR) of an abdominal aortic aneurysm is a rare condition, and differential diagnosis might be difficult. We present a clinical case of a hemodynamically stable octogenarian who presented with intermittent pain in the left lower abdomen. The patient had a history of diverticulitis, and 6 years ago, he had undergone endovascular abdominal aortic aneurysm repair (EVAR) with a Talent bifurcated prosthesis. Additionally, 20 days before his admission to our hospital, he had undergone a secondary iliac limb extension for treatment of post-EVAR rupture. On admission, abdominal plain radiography identified suprarenal fixation fracture as a possible reason for CCR, but computed tomographic angiography failed to confirm any endoleak or "active" bleeding and rupture. The patient received medication treatment for possible diverticulitis and was kept under close monitoring for suspected failure of recently performed secondary endovascular procedure and CCR. A day later, the abdominal pain symptoms worsened, and a new computed tomographic angiography confirmed the suspected CCR. The patient was treated successfully by "open" repair using a Y prosthesis. To our knowledge, this is the first reported case of post-EVAR CCR due to suprarenal fixation fatigue fracture. Lifelong post-EVAR follow-up with high level of both clinical and imaging diagnostic accuracy is essential for the early recognition and proper treatment of EVAR pitfalls.