Hydroxylation of l-phenylalanine (Phe) by hydroxyl radical (*OH) yields 4-, 3-, and 2-hydroxyl-Phe (para-, meta-, and ortho-tyrosine, respectively). Phe derivative measurements have been employed to detect *OH formation in cells and tissues, however, the specificity of this assay is limited since Phe derivatives also arise from intracellular Phe hydroxylase. d-Phe, the d-type enantiomer, is not hydroxylated by Phe hydroxylase. We evaluate whether d-Phe reacts with *OH as well as l-Phe, providing a more reliable probe for *OH generation in biological systems. With *OH generated by a Fenton reaction or xanthine oxidase, d- and l-Phe equally gave rise to p, m, o-tyr and this could be prevented by *OH scavengers. Resting human neutrophils (PMNs) markedly converted l-Phe to p-tyr, through non-oxidant-mediated reactions, whereas d-Phe was unaffected. In contrast, when PMNs were stimulated in the presence of redox cycling iron the *OH formed resulted in more significant rise of p-tyr from d-Phe (9.4-fold) than l-Phe (3.6-fold) due to the significant background formation of p-tyr from l-Phe. Together, these data indicated that d- and l-Phe were equally hydroxylated by *OH. Using d-Phe instead of l-Phe can eliminate the formation of Phe derivatives from Phe hydroxylase and achieve more specific, sensitive measurement of *OH in biological systems.