ABSTRACT The prevailing method to produce plastic‐bonded explosive (PBX) molding powder, or “prills”, is a complex, multiphase, and bespoke process that was developed by the high explosives (HEs) manufacturing industry several decades ago. This article demonstrates the utility of a simpler, widely‐used mechanical process—extrusion‐spheronization—to produce PBX prills. We begin by detailing precautions taken to enable safe remote operation of extrusion‐spheronization equipment with HE. We then perform a study investigating the effect of lacquer solvent composition on the particle packing, pressed density, and compressive strength properties of a 95 wt.% TATB/5 wt.% polymer binder formulation akin to PBX 9502. It was found that increased composition of low vapor pressure solvents caused prolonged retention of the solvent, resulting in tackier materials that would agglomerate and form larger prills. The larger prills also led to lower poured density and tapped density of HE prills and compressive strength of pressed PBX articles. The samples prepared with a 75% propyl acetate/25% butyl acetate lacquer solvent composition exhibited the highest compressive strength. However, it is believed that the prill packing and compressive strength properties are primarily driven by the prill size rather than the chemical composition of the lacquer itself. Extrusion‐spheronization remains a promising method to reliably and repeatably produce HE prills that is less sensitive to feedstock or process variation than traditional methods.