Abstract In this paper, the variability in static strengths of six glass fiber‐reinforced sheet molding compounds (SMC) is reported. This variability was shown not to be caused by macroscopic variations in fiber, resin, filler, or void content nor gross fiber anisotropy. Weibull statistics were used to accurately characterize this variability, Random flaw models with the flaws being distributed in the volume, surface, or edge were shown not to predict the observed static strength variability in SMC.