AbstractWhereas consumer satisfaction is critical for the success of services, we research how providers evaluate customers in the sharing economy represented by the rideshare marketplace. We examine anticipated customer evaluation (ACE) as the underlying link and the provider's sense of power as a moderator for the relationship between customer ingratiation and provider evaluations. We first conducted a field pilot study and analyzed the content of rideshare trips described by drivers. Then, we tested the conceptual framework in four experiments that manipulated different rideshare customer behaviors (self‐presentation, other‐enhancement, and customer conformity). Our study contributes to the consumer research literature by examining provider evaluation and discovering the peer‐to‐peer (P2P) dynamic evaluation mechanisms that adopt a two‐way rating system.