AbstractThe influence of oily molecules on the structure of liquid water is a question of importance to biology and geology and many other fields. Previous experimental, theoretical, and simulation studies of methane in liquid water have reached widely conflicting conclusions regarding the structure of hydrophobic hydration‐shells. Herein we address this question by performing Raman hydration‐shell vibrational spectroscopic measurements of methane in liquid water from −10 °C to 300 °C (at 30 MPa, along a path that parallels the liquid‐vapor coexistence curve). We show that, near ambient temperatures, methane's hydration‐shell is slightly more tetrahedral than pure water. Moreover, the hydration‐shell undergoes a crossover to a more disordered structure above ca. 85 °C. Comparisons with the crossover temperature of aqueous methanol (and other alcohols) reveal the stabilizing influence of an alcohol OH head‐group on hydrophobic hydration‐shell fragility.