EMG filling curve characterizes the EMG filling process and EMG probability density function (PDF) shape change for the entire force range of a muscle. We aim to understand the relation between the physiological and recording variables, and the resulting EMG filling curves. We thereby present an analytical and simulation study to explain how the filling curve patterns relate to specific changes in the motor unit potential (MUP) waveforms and motor unit (MU) firing rates, the two main factors affecting the EMG PDF, but also to recording conditions in terms of noise level. We compare the analytical results with simulated cases verifying a perfect agreement with the analytical model. Finally, we present a set of real EMG filling curves with distinct patterns to explain the information about MUP amplitudes, MU firing rates, and noise level that these patterns provide in the light of the analytical study. Our findings reflect that the filling factor increases when firing rate increases or when newly recruited motor unit have potentials of smaller or equal amplitude than the former ones. On the other hand, the filling factor decreases when newly recruited potentials are larger in amplitude than the previous potentials. Filling curves are shown to be consistent under changes of the MUP waveform, and stretched under MUP amplitude scaling. Our findings also show how additive noise affects the filling curve and can even impede to obtain reliable information from the EMG PDF statistics.