Hepatic proteomes are intricately controlled through biosynthesis, extracellular secretion, and intrahepatic degradation. Autophagy governs lysosome‐mediated intrahepatic degradation and the hepatic proteome. When autophagy is impaired, it leads to the accumulation of intrahepatic proteins, causing proteinopathy. This study investigates whether autophagy can modulate the hepatic proteome non‐degradatively. Utilizing conditional, inducible, and hepatotoxin models of hepatic autophagy impairment, we assessed the overall hepatic proteome expression using Coomassie brilliant blue (CBB) staining and liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry (LC/MS). We pinpointed and confirmed four specific hepatic proteins—Cps1, Ahcy, Ca3, and Gstm1—that were selectively modified in autophagy‐deficient livers. Expression of Cps1, Ahcy, and Ca3 were significantly reduced, while Gstm1 expression increased in livers with autophagy impairment. Interestingly, these changes in hepatic protein levels were not due to defective autophagic degradation but were associated with alterations in mRNA transcript levels. Moreover, as a result of autophagic dysfunction, sustained activation of the nuclear erythroid‐derived 2‐like 2 (Nrf2) transcription factor, transcriptionally regulated the mRNA levels of these proteins. Our findings indicate that autophagy can influence hepatic proteins not solely via traditional degradative routes but also through non‐degradative transcriptional processes by modulating Nrf2.