Fungi are opportunistic eukaryotic entities often taking advantage of susceptibilities offered by a host due to its immunocompromised status, changed microbiome, or ruptured physical barriers and eventually cause infections. They either invade the skin superficially or are deep-seated. Superficial mycosis affects the skin, hair, and nails inhabiting the outermost layer, stratum corneum. In the present study, we report a case of superficial mycosis (onychomycosis in particular) in a 45-year-old immunocompetent man who was an ex-defense personnel and presently serving as a security guard at the University of Jammu, District Jammu, Jammu and Kashmir, India. The infection evolved 17 years ago and negatively affected the quality of life of the patient. For the identification of the causal agent, direct microscopy, cultural, micro-morphological, molecular characterization (ITS sequencing), and phylogenetic analysis were taken into account. A mucoralean fungal species, Thamnostylum piriforme, was isolated from the fingernails (left hand) of the investigated patient, which represents a new global report as the causal agent of superficial mycosis. In vitro antifungal susceptibility testing showed T. piriforme sensitivity to itraconazole, amphotericin B and ketoconazole while resistance to fluconazole. Careful selection of optimal therapy for fungal infection based primarily on correct identification and antifungal susceptibility testing could provide effective results during treatment against these opportunistic human fungal pathogens.