• shareshare
  • link
  • cite
  • add
auto_awesome_motion View all 4 versions
Publication . Other literature type . Part of book or chapter of book . 2010

Changing authority relations within French academic research units since the 1960s: from patronage to partnership

Severine Louvel;
Open Access
Published: 01 Jan 2010
Publisher: HAL CCSD
Country: France

This chapter casts light on some intra-organizational consequences of the structural transformations which have affected the French public science system since the 1960s, particularly how relations of authority between the directors of research units and their team leaders have shifted from the "patronage" type dominant in the 1960s to the "partnership" type prevailing today. More open and competitive academic labour markets have restricted the directors' direct influence on recruitments and promotions; a gradual increase of contractual funding puts an end to their monopoly over contract management; and the formalization of assessment procedures limits his advocacy role on behalf of their teams. The authority of directors over their teams seems to have diminished along with this transition. However directors still play a mediating role between their teams and the external environment and they can still provide the team's strategic resources. Furthermore, they partly contribute to the teams' ability to bridge and to buffer themselves against their external environments (Meznar and Nigh, 1995). Finally, the transition observed here can be considered as one of the micro sociological expressions of a broader trend also occurring in other countries, which can be characterized as the evolution of state-coordinated public science systems towards more state-shared ones, and even perhaps moving to a limited form of state-delegated ones (Whitley in this volume). In this type of public research system, funding agencies and the administrative heads of research institutions effectively act to restrain the authority of the scientific elites (such as the research laboratory directors).


authority relations, academic research, research units, organizational change, France, [SHS.SOCIO]Humanities and Social Sciences/Sociology, [SHS.SOCIO] Humanities and Social Sciences/Sociology

20 references, page 1 of 2

BLAU, P. (1967) Exchange and Power in Social Life, New York, Wiley and sons.

BOLTANSKI, L. & THÉVENOT, L. (2006) On Justification. The Economies of Worth, Princeton, Princeton University Press.

CERC (1992) Les enseignants-chercheurs de l'enseignement supérieur : revenus professionnels et conditions d'activité. Document n°105. Centre d'études sur les revenus et les coûts.

CLARK, T. N. (1973) Prophets and patrons; the French university and the emergence of the social sciences, Cambridge, London, Harvard University Press.

CNER (2003) Evaluation de la recherche publique dans les établissements publics français. Paris, La Documentation française.

EISENHARDT, K. M. (1991) Better Stories and Better Constructs: the Case for Rigor and Comparative Logic. Academic of Management Review, 16, 620-627.

ETZKOWITZ, H. & KEMELGOR, C. (1998) The Role of Research Centres in the Collectivisation of Academic Science. Minerva: A Review of Science, Learning & Policy, 36, 271-288.

FIXARI, D., MOISDON, J.-C. & PALLEZ, F. (1993) Gérer en évaluant. Le rôle du Comité National de la Recherche Scientifique. Paris, Centre de Recherches en Gestion, Ecole des Mines.

FRENCH NEUROSCIENCE SOCIETY (2006) Bibliométrie : l'avis des Présidents de section. La Lettre des Neurosciences, 14.

GEIGER, R. L. (1990) Organized Research Units. Their Role in the Development of University Research. The Journal of Higher Education, 61, 1-19.

Download fromView all 2 sources
Hyper Article en Ligne
Other literature type . 2010