publication . Article . 2012

The Vulnerable Subject of Negligence Law

Carl F. Stychin;
Open Access
  • Published: 01 Sep 2012 Journal: International Journal of Law in Context, volume 8, pages 337-353 (issn: 1744-5523, eissn: 1744-5531, Copyright policy)
  • Publisher: Cambridge University Press (CUP)
  • Country: United Kingdom
Abstract
<jats:title>Abstract</jats:title><jats:p>The approach taken by English courts to the duty of care question in negligence has been subject to harsh criticism in recent years. This article examines this fundamental issue in tort law, drawing upon Canadian and Australian jurisprudence by way of comparison. From this analysis, the concept of vulnerability is developed as a productive means of understanding the duty of care. Vulnerability is of increasing interest in legal and political theory and it is of particular relevance to the law of negligence. In addition to aiding doctrinal coherence, vulnerability – with its focus on relationships and care – has the potent...
Subjects
free text keywords: Law, K1, Autonomy, media_common.quotation_subject, media_common, Jurisprudence, Political philosophy, Comparative law, Sociology, Tort, Delict, Negligence Law, Duty of care
Related Organizations
52 references, page 1 of 4

atkins, Peter J., hassan, M. Manzurul and dunn, Christine E. (2006) 'Toxic Torts: Arsenic Poisoning in Bangladesh and the Legal Geographies of Responsibility', Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 31: 272-85. [OpenAIRE]

barker, Andrew (2003) 'The Duty of Care and the Search for Certainty: Sullivan v. Moody, Cooper v. Hobart, and the Problems in the South Pacific', New Zealand Law Journal: 44-48.

barker, Kit (1993) 'Unreliable Assumptions in the Modern Law of Negligence', Law Quarterly Review 109: 461-84.

barnett, Clive and land, David (2007) 'Geographies of Generosity: Beyond the “Moral Turn”', Geoforum 38: 1065-75.

beever, Allan (2003) 'Particularism and Prejudice in the Law of Tort', Tort Law Review 11: 146-67.

beever, Allan (2007) Rediscovering the Law of Negligence. Oxford: Hart Publishing.

beever, Allan (2008) 'Corrective Justice and Personal Responsibility in Tort Law', Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 28: 475-500. [OpenAIRE]

brown, Russell (2003) 'Still Crazy After All These Years: Anns, Cooper v. Hobart and Pure Economic Loss', University of British Columbia Law Review 36: 159-91.

brown, Russell (2005) 'Justifying the Impossibility of Recoverable Relational Economic Loss', Oxford University Commonwealth Law Journal 5: 155-78.

brown, Russell and brochu, Shannon (2008) 'Once More Unto the Breach: James v. British Columbia and Problems with the Duty of Care in Canadian Tort Law', Alberta Law Review 45: 1071-88.

52 Thus, I recognise the potential relevance of distributive justice concerns which might preclude a duty, but I advocate that those issues be raised explicitly. Of course, vulnerability could sometimes also inform the distributive justice inquiry.

conaghan, Joanne (2003) 'Tort Law and Feminist Critique', in M. D. A. Freeman (ed.), Current Legal Problems. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 175-209. [OpenAIRE]

drakopoulou, Maria (2000) 'The Ethic of Care, Female Subjectivity and Feminist Legal Scholarship', Feminist Legal Studies 8: 199-226.

fineman, Martha Albertson (2008-2009) 'The Vulnerable Subject: Anchoring Equality in the Human Condition', Yale Journal of Law and Feminism 20: 1-23.

george, James (2002) 'Watson v. British Boxing Board of Control: Negligent Rule-Making in the Court of Appeal', Modern Law Review 65: 106-119.

52 references, page 1 of 4
Any information missing or wrong?Report an Issue