Assumptions behind grammatical approaches to code-switching: when the blueprint is a red herring

Article English OPEN
Gardner-Chloros, Penelope ; Edwards, Malcolm (2004)

Many of the so-called ‘grammars’ of code-switching are based on various underlying assumptions, e.g. that informal speech can be adequately or appropriately described in terms of ‘‘grammar’’; that deep, rather than surface, structures are involved in code-switching; that one ‘language’ is the ‘base’ or ‘matrix’; and that constraints derived from existing data are universal and predictive. We question these assumptions on several grounds. First, ‘grammar’ is arguably distinct from the processes driving speech production. Second, the role of grammar is mediated by the variable, poly-idiolectal repertoires of bilingual speakers. Third, in many instances of CS the notion of a ‘base’ system is either irrelevant, or fails to explain the facts. Fourth, sociolinguistic factors frequently override ‘grammatical’ factors, as evidence from the same language pairs in different settings has shown. No principles proposed to date account for all the facts, and it seems unlikely that ‘grammar’, as conventionally conceived, can provide definitive answers. We conclude that rather than seeking universal, predictive grammatical rules, research on CS should focus on the variability of bilingual grammars.
  • References (21)
    21 references, page 1 of 3

    AAHO, T., 1999. Codeswitching in the Greek Cypriot Community in London.MA Thesis, Univ. of Helsinki, Dept. of English.

    ALFONZETTI, G., 1999. 'The Conversational Dimension in Code-switching between Italian and Dialect in Sicily', in P. Auer (ed.) 180-214.

    ALVAREZ-CACCAMO, C., 1999. 'From 'switching code' to 'code-switching': towards a reconceptualization of communicative codes', in P. Auer (ed.) 29-50.

    AUER, P. (ed.), 1998. Code-switching in Conversation: Language, Interaction and Identity. London & New York: Routledge.

    BACKUS, A., 1999. 'The intergenerational codeswitching continuum in an immigrant community', in G. Extra and L. Verhoeven (eds.) Bilingualism and Migration, Berlin: Mouton.

    BELAZI, H., RUBIN,E.&TORIBIO, J., 1994. 'Code-switching and X-bar theory: the Functional Head Constraint', Linguistic Inquiry 25, 221-237.

    BENTAHILA,A. & DAVIES, E. E., 1983. 'The syntax of Arabic-French code-switching', Lingua 59, 301-330.

    BENTAHILA,A.& DAVIES, E. E., 1991. 'Constraints on code-switching: a look beyond grammar'. Papers for the symposium on code-switching in bilingual studies: theory, significance and perspectives. Barcelona, March 1991: European Science Foundation, 369-405.

    BERK-SELIGSON, S., 1986. 'Linguistic constraints on intra-sentential code-switching: a study of Spanish-Hebrew bilingualism', Language in Society 15, 313-48.

    BOESCHOTEN, H., 1991. 'Asymmetrical Code-switching in Immigrant Communities', in Proceedings of the Workshop on Constraints, Conditions and Models. European Science Foundation, Strasbourg, 85-104.

  • Metrics
    views in OpenAIRE
    views in local repository
    downloads in local repository

    The information is available from the following content providers:

    From Number Of Views Number Of Downloads
    Birkbeck Institutional Research Online - IRUS-UK 0 130
Share - Bookmark