Of scales, networks and assemblages: the League of Nations apparatus and the scalar sovereignty of the Government of India

Article English OPEN
Legg, Stephen (2009)

Whilst greatly valuing recent critiques of the vertical imaginary and reified ontology of scale theory, and of the unfettered flows of network theory, this paper argues against a human geography without scale. Rather, four propositions from the theoretical literature are used to provide a tool-kit to analyse the practical negotiation of scalar politics, namely that: scales should be considered as effects, not frames or structures, of practice; networks must be considered in all their complexity and heterogeneity; networks can be interpreted as assemblages, the more re-territorialising and re-scaling of which can be analysed as apparatuses; and that state apparatuses work to create the impression that scales are ahistorical, hierarchical and possess exclusive relationships. These propositions are used to explore a period of history when the scalar constitution of the world was under intense debate. The interwar era saw the imperial scale clash with that of the international, both as ideological worldviews, and as a series of interacting institutions. The assemblages of internationalism and imperialism were embodied by apparatuses such as the League of Nations and the colonial Government of India respectively. Attempts by the League to encourage the abolition of tolerated brothels in an attempt to reduce the trafficking of women and children led to intense debates between the 1920s and 1930s over what constituted the legitimate domains of the international and the ‘domestic’. These explicitly scalar debates were the product of League networks that threatened the scalar sovereignty of the Raj, most directly through the travelling Commission of Enquiry into Traffic in Women and Children in the East in 1931.
  • References (101)
    101 references, page 1 of 11

    Agamben G 1998 Homo sacer: sovereign power and bare life Stanford University Press, Stanford CA

    Agamben G 2005 State of exception University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL

    Allen J 2003 Lost geographies of power Blackwell, Oxford

    Anghie A 2004 Imperialism, sovereignty and the making of international law Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

    Aradau C 2007 Law transformed: Guantanamo and the 'other' exception Third World Quarterly 28 489-501

    Balakrishnan G 2000 The enemy: an intellectual portrait of Carl Schmitt Verso, London

    Ballantyne T and Burton A 2005 Introduction: bodies, empires and world histories in Ballantyne T and Burton A eds Bodies in contact: rethinking colonial encounters in world history Duke University Press, Durham NC 1-15

    Ballhatchet K 1980 Race, sex and class under the Raj: imperial attitudes and policies and their critics, 1793-1905 Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London

    Barry A 2001 Political machines: governing a technological society The Athlone Press, London

    Barry K 1995 The prostitution of sexuality: the global exploitation of women New York University Press, New York

  • Metrics
    No metrics available
Share - Bookmark