Negotiated plea agreements in cases of serious and complex fraud in England and Wales: a new conceptualisation of plea bargaining?

Article English OPEN
Alge, Daniele (2013)
  • Subject: Law | Criminal-justice

This article examines negotiated plea agreements introduced by the Attorney General in 2009 for cases of serious or complex fraud, and the degree to which these differ from plea agreements reached through informal plea bargaining in other types of criminal case. It first considers whether the formally negotiated agreements are a result of coercion being brought to bear on defendants, or of defendants ‘playing the system’ (the two most common criticisms of ordinary plea bargains). It is then argued that an alternative conceptualisation may be more appropriate in serious fraud cases. To this end, approaches to plea bargaining more commonly applied in the United States (consensual, concessions, and contractual models) are considered in light of the current context. It is submitted that whilst these approaches have only limited application to defendants in ordinary criminal cases, they may help explain the dynamic of plea agreements in serious fraud cases. This in turn provides a basis upon which to assess the fairness of negotiated pleas in serious fraud cases, and highlights issues which lie at the core of the plea bargaining debate.
  • References (6)

    Alexander R 'The Bribery Act 2010 in force: an opportunity to be taken' (2011) 32 Company Lawyer 353

    Alschuler A W 'The defense attorney's role in plea bargaining' (1975) 84 Yale Law Journal 1179

    Ashworth A. and Redmayne, M. The Criminal Process Oxford: (OUP 2005) Attorney General's Office (2008) Press Release: 'Criminal Justice Measures to Enhance Fraud Prosecutions to be Introduced' 18th March 2009.

    Attorney General's Office Guidelines on Plea Discussions in Cases of Serious or Complex Fraud (London: Attorney General's Office 2009)

    Baldwin J and McConville M Negotiated Justice: Pressures to Plead Guilty (London: Martin Robertson 1977)

    'Plea Bargaining and Plea Negotiation in England' (1979) 13 Law & Society Review 287

  • Metrics
    views in OpenAIRE
    views in local repository
    downloads in local repository

    The information is available from the following content providers:

    From Number Of Views Number Of Downloads
    UWL Repository - IRUS-UK 0 77
Share - Bookmark