Infrastructure, planning and the command of time

Article English OPEN
Marshall, Tim ; Cowell, Richard John Westley (2016)

Governments in many countries have sought to accelerate the time taken to make\ud decisions on major infrastructure projects, citing problems of ‘delay’. Despite this, rarely\ud has the time variable been given careful empirical or conceptual attention in decisionmaking\ud generally, or in infrastructure decision-making specifically. This paper addresses\ud this deficit by analysing decision-making on two categories of major infrastructure in the\ud UK – transport and electricity generation – seeking both to generate better evidence of\ud the changes to decision times in recent decades, and to generate insights from treating\ud time as resource and tracking its (re)allocation. We find that reforms introduced since\ud 2008 have done relatively little to alter overall decision times, but that there are marked\ud and revealing changes to the allocation of time between decision-making stages. While\ud public planning processes have their time frames tightly regulated, aspects led by\ud developers (e.g. pre-application discussion) are not; arranging finance can have a bigger\ud effect on project time frames, and central government retains much flexibility to manage\ud the flow of time. Speed-up reforms are also sectorally uneven in their reach. This\ud indicates how arguments for time discipline falter in the face of infrastructure projects\ud that remain profoundly politicised.
  • References (19)
    19 references, page 1 of 2

    Agamben G, 2005, State of Exception, (University of Chicago Press, Chicago)

    Allmendinger P, 2011, New Labour and Planning. From New Right to New Left, (Routledge: London).

    Bachrach P, Baratz M, 1962 “The two faces of power” The American Political Science Review, 56, 947-952.

    Ball M, Allmendinger P, Hughes C, 2009, “Housing supply and planning delay in the south of England”, Journal of European Real Estate Research, 22(1), 151-169

    Barker K, 2006, Barker Review of Land Use Planning, Interim Report, July (HM Treasury, London)

    BBC, 2015, Queen's Speech 2015 - bill by bill, 27th May,, accessed 13th August 2015.

    Blowers A, 2009, “Why dump on us?” Town and Country Planning, 78 (1) 33-37.

    Booth P, 2002, “A desperately slow system? The origins and nature of the current discourse on development control”, Planning Perspectives, 17, 309-323

    Brand P, Watson P, 2013, “The resurgence of 'government': recent policy initiatives and the new legitimacy crisis”, AESOP / ACSP Congress Dublin, July 15-19th 2013

    BMVBS (Federal Ministry of Transportation, Building and Urban Development) (2012) „Handbuch für eine gute Bürgerbeteiligung“ zur Planung von Großvorhaben im Verkehrssektor, BerlinCBI, 2000, Manifesto: Towards 2010, (CBI, London)

  • Metrics
    No metrics available
Share - Bookmark