Algorithmic States of Exception

Article English OPEN
McQuillan, Daniel (2015)
  • Publisher: SAGE Publications

In this paper I argue that pervasive tracking and data-mining are leading to shifts in governmentality that can be characterised as algorithmic states of exception. I also argue that the apparatus that performs this change owes as much to everyday business models as it does to mass surveillance. I look at technical changes at the level of data structures, such as the move to NoSQL databases, and how this combines with data-mining and machine learning to accelerate the use of prediction as a form of governance. The consequent confusion between correlation and causation leads, I assert, to the creation of states of exception. I set out what I mean by states of exception using the ideas of Giorgio Agamben, focusing on the aspects most relevant to algorithmic regulation: force-of and topology. I argue that the effects of these states of exception escape legal constraints such as concepts of privacy. Having characterised this as a potentially totalising change and an erosion of civil liberties, I ask in what ways the states of exception might be opposed. I follow Agamben by drawing on Walter Benjamin's concept of pure means as a tactic that is itself outside the frame of law-producing or law-preserving activity. However, the urgent need to respond requires more than a philosophical stance, and I examine two examples of historical resistance that satisfy Benjamin's criteria. For each in turn I draw connections to contemporary cases of digital dissent that exhibit some of the same characteristics. I conclude that it is possible both theoretically and practically to resist the coming states of exception and I end by warning what is at stake if we do not.
  • References (7)

    Agamben G (2005) State of Exception. 1 edition. Chicago: University Of Chicago Press.

    Benjamin W (1995) Reflections: Essays, Aphorisms, Autobiographical Writings. 1st Schocken edition edition. New York: Random House USA Inc.

    Benjamin W (2009) On The Concept of History. New York: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform.

    Black E (2012) IBM and the Holocaust: The Strategic Alliance Between Nazi Germany and America's Most Powerful Corporation-Expanded Edition. Expanded edition. Washington, D.C.: Dialog Press.

    Bland E (2010) Software predicts criminal behavior., Available from: cts-criminal-behavior/ (accessed 2 May 2014).

    Blum-Dumontet E (2012) There is No Party Like a CryptoParty. The Huffington Post UK, Available from: 3705.html (accessed 16 May 2014).

    Boyd D and Crawford K (2011) Six Provocations for Big Data. SSRN Scholarly Paper, Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network, Available from:

  • Metrics
    No metrics available
Share - Bookmark