A “lingering diminuendo”? The Conference on Devolution 1919-1920

Doctoral thesis English OPEN
Evans, Adam B.
  • Subject: JN101

This thesis offers the first detailed assessment of an event that has hitherto been consigned to the margins of the literature on devolution and territorial reform in the United Kingdom, the Conference on Devolution, 1919-1920. Sitting between October 1919 and April 1920, the Conference on Devolution was arguably one of the two moments in the UK’s constitutional history when the territorial constitution was approached in a holistic fashion by policy makers and political elites (the other occasion being the Royal Commission on the Constitution, 1969-1973). \ud \ud The primary aim of this thesis is to provide the first detailed analysis of the Conference on Devolution, to develop a fuller understanding of why it was established, what it debated and why it failed. Secondary to that objective, this thesis will also assess what relevance the Conference has for students of territorial governance in the UK today, at a time when the UK’s constitution is in flux. In pursuit of these objectives, the thesis utilises the ideas and insights on territorial governance of James Bulpitt and James Mitchell, alongside an extensive catalogue of archival evidence, including the previously unstudied (in the context of the Conference on Devolution) personal papers of the Conference’s Secretary, Gilbert Campion.\ud \ud Using this methodology and archival sources, the thesis offers a considerable revision to previous understandings of the Conference on Devolution. It demonstrates that the Conference’s fatal disagreement on how the devolved legislatures should be composed, was not, as has been previously portrayed, just a disagreement at the latter stages of the Conference’s work, but was instead a cleavage that undercut the entirety of the Conference on Devolution. Finally, the thesis highlights the clear resonance between the issues deliberated by the Conference and many of today’s territorial governance debates.
  • References (4)

    Hardy, L., J.F. Mason, A. Shirley Benn, J.W. Hills, G.R. Lane-Fox, L. Wilson, W. Astor, E. Wood, G. Lloyd. (16th April 1918). Case for a Prompt Settlement: An Appeal of Unionists, The Times, p.7

    “An Irishman”. (19th March 1918). The Irish Difficulty: A Suggestion, The Times, p.8 Murray, G. (17th May 1921). Devolution: An invitation to the Government, The Times, p.16

    Oliver, F.S. (23rd May 1918). Federalism: Joseph Chamberlain's Policy, The Times, p.2 Oliver, F.S. (21st May 1918). Federalism: the Imperial Necessity, The Times, p.8 The Times. (19th February 1969). Obituary: Captain Cyril Driver, The Times, p.10 The Times. (3rd May 1963). Obituary: Lord Gorell, The Times, p.17 The Times. (18th January 1947). Obituary: Lord Southborough, The Times, p.7 The Times. (5th February 1945). Obituary: Lord Charnwood, The Times, p.6 The Times. (19th October 1935). Obituary: The Duke of Buccleuch, The Times, p.14 The Times. (19th September 1932). Obituary: Lord Stafford, The Times, p.14 The Times. (24th May 1932). Obituary: Lord Inchape, The Times, p.19 The Times. (22nd July 1930). Obituary: Lord Dufferin, The Times, p.16 The Times. (21st February 1929). Obituary: Lord Aberdare, The Times, p.18 The Times. (1st July 1927). Obituary: Lord Oranmore and Browne, The Times, p.19 The Times. (30th April 1921). Federal Devolution, The Times, p.11 The Times. (29th April 1921). Federal Devolution, The Times, p.7 The Times. (20th December 1920). Our overworked Parliament: Empire and Doorstep Legislation, Prime Minister on Reform, The Times, p.14 The Times. (25th November 1920). Parliament: Government of Ireland Bill, The Times, p.16

    The Times. (6th July 1920). Editorial. The Times, p.15 The Times. (13th May 1920). Devolution, The Times, p.17 The Times. (18th February 1920). Devolution by Grand Councils, The Times, p.16 The Times. (13th November 1919). Obituary: Lord Brassey, The Times, p.14 The Times. (7th November 1919). The Devolution Conference, The Times, p.13 The Times. (29th October 1919). Devolution Conference at Work, The Times, p.12 The Times. (2nd October 1919). Ulster Covenant, The Times, p.9 The Times. (26th July 1919). “The Times” Scheme, The Times, p.13 The Times. (11th July 1919). Federal Devolution, The Times, p.17 The Times. (11th July 1919). Devolution for Wales, The Times, p.17 The Times. (6th June 1919). The Devolution Inquiry, The Times, p.18 The Times. (29th July 1918). Labour and Home Rule All Round, The Times, p.4 The Times. (1st July 1918). Prime Minister's Statement, The Times, p.9 The Times. (21st May 1918). Federalism: the Imperial Necessity, The Times, p.8

  • Metrics
    0
    views in OpenAIRE
    0
    views in local repository
    117
    downloads in local repository

    The information is available from the following content providers:

    From Number Of Views Number Of Downloads
    Online Research @ Cardiff - IRUS-UK 0 117
Share - Bookmark