Can a nudge keep you warm? Using nudges to reduce excess winter deaths: insight from the Keeping Warm in Later Life Project (KWILLT)

Article English OPEN
Allmark, Peter ; Tod, Angela (2013)
  • Publisher: Oxford University Press
  • Journal: Journal of Public Health (Oxford, England), volume 36, issue 1, pages 111-116 (issn: 1741-3842, eissn: 1741-3850)
  • Related identifiers: doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdt067, pmc: PMC3935492
  • Subject: social determinants | affordable warmth | behavioural economics | fuel poverty | Health Improvement | excess winter deaths | nudge

Nudges are interventions that aim to change people's behaviour through changing the environment in which they choose rather than appealing to their reasoning. Nudges have been proposed as of possible use in relation to health-related behaviour. However, nudges have been criticized as ethically dubious because they bypass peoples reasoning and (anyway) are of little help in relation to affecting ill-health that results from social determinants, such as poverty. Reducing the rate of excess winter deaths (EWDs) is a public health priority; however, EWD seems clearly to be socially determined such that nudges arguably have little role. This article defends two claims: (i) nudges could have a place in tackling even the heavily socially determined problem of EWD. We draw on evidence from an empirical study, the Keeping Warm in Later Life Project (KWILLT), to argue that in some cases the risk of cold is within the person’s control to some extent such that environmental modifications to influence behaviour such as nudges are possible. (ii) Some uses of behavioural insights in the form of nudges are acceptable, including some in the area of EWD. We suggest a question-based framework by which to judge the ethical acceptability of nudges.
  • References (17)
    17 references, page 1 of 2

    Excess winter deaths in England.

    Improving outcomes and supporting transparency. Part 1: A public health outcomes framework for England 2012–2016.

    Fuel poverty, England and the UK. 2011

    Macmillan, T. Nudge politics. Food Ethics. 2011; 6: 3

    Cold weather plan for England: protecting health and reducing harm from severe cold weather.

    Excess winter deaths and illnesses (project outline).

    Verweij, M, Van den Hoven, M. Nudges in public health: paternalism is paramount. Am J Bioeth. 2012; 12: 1-3

    Hausman, DM, Welch, B. Debate: to nudge or not to nudge. J Polit Philos. 2010; 18: 123-36

    Tod, AM, Lusambili, A, Homer, C, Abbott, J, Cooke, JM, Stocks, J, McDaid, K. Understanding factors influencing vulnerable older people keeping warm and well in winter: a qualitative study using social marketing techniques. BMJ Open. 2012; 2: e000922

    The health impacts of cold homes and fuel poverty.

  • Metrics
    No metrics available
Share - Bookmark