Conversational pursuit of medication compliance in a Therapeutic Community for persons diagnosed with mental disorders

Article English OPEN
Mortari, Luigina ; Pino, Marco (2014)
  • Publisher: Informa Healthcare
  • Journal: Disability and Rehabilitation, volume 36, issue 17, pages 1,419-1,430 (issn: 0963-8288, eissn: 1464-5165)
  • Related identifiers: doi: 10.3109/09638288.2013.834987, pmc: PMC4219849
  • Subject: compliance | medication | mental health and illness | Communication | Research Paper | Therapeutic Community

Purpose In this article, we contribute to the debate on medication compliance by exploring the conversational “technologies” entailed in the process of promoting clients’ adherence to psychopharmacological prescriptions. Using a case study approach, we explore how medication-related problems are dealt with in conversational interaction between the staff members and the clients of a mental health Therapeutic Community (TC) in Italy. Method Four meetings between two staff members (Barbara and Massimo) and the clients of the TC were audio-recorded. The data were transcribed and analyzed using the method of Conversation Analysis. Results Barbara and Massimo recur to practices of topic articulation to promote talk that references the clients’ failure to take the medications. Through these practices they deal with the practical problem of mobilizing the clients’ cooperation in courses of action that fit into the institutional agenda of fostering medication adherence. Conclusions Barbara and Massimo’s conversational practices appear to reflect the assumption that medication-related problems can be reduced to compliance problems. This assumption works to make the clients accountable for their failure to take the medications while shaping a conversational environment that is unreceptive to their complaints about side effects. Implications for the understanding of mental health rehabilitation practice in TCs are discussed. Implications of RehabilitationTherapeutic community staff members should be aware of the challenges and blocks in communicating with their clients.Therapeutic communities can promote staff members’ awareness of communication challenges through reflective workshops in which they can jointly view and comment on interaction with their clients.Reflective workshops can be used to raise awareness of the presuppositions underlying therapeutic community staff members’ communication practices.
  • References (29)
    29 references, page 1 of 3

    1. Scheid-Cook TL. The validity of social control critiques: psychiatric medication, side effects and outpatient commitment. Sociol Focus 1991;24:59-77.

    2. National Institute of Mental Health. Mental Health Medications. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services; 2010.

    3. Barrett KE, Taylor DW, Pullo RE, Dunlap DA. The right to refuse medication: navigating the ambiguity. Psychiatr Rehabil J 1998;21: 241-9.

    4. Fisher DB. Comments on the article, ''The right to refuse medication: navigating the ambiguity''. Psychiatr Rehabil J 1998; 21:250-1.

    5. Gottstein JB. Psychiatrists' failure to inform: Is there substantial financial exposure? Ethic Human Psychol Psychiatry 2007;9: 117-25.

    6. Gomory T. The origins of coercion in assertive community treatment: a review of early publications from the special treatment unit of Mendota State Hospital. Ethic Human Sci Serv 2002;4:3-16.

    7. Brodwin P. The assemblage of compliance in psychiatric case management. Anthropol Med 2010;17:129-43.

    8. Sidnell J. Conversation analysis: an introduction. Malden (MA): Wiley-Blackwell; 2010.

    9. Denman A, Wilkinson R. Applying conversation analysis to traumatic brain injury: investigating touching another person in everyday social interaction. Disabil Rehabil 2011;33:243-52.

    10. Svennevig J. The agenda as resource for topic introduction in workplace meetings. Discourse Stud 2012;14:53-66.

  • Metrics
    No metrics available
Share - Bookmark