Why Appoint Professionals? A Student Cataloguing Project
Students have provided cheap successful labour for routine retrospective cataloguing\ud projects. The current article examines a library project which went further, using\ud university students with minimum training to catalogue its undergraduate stock from\ud the book in hand to AACR2, level 2, allegedly to professional standard. The article discusses the faults made in MARC coding, descriptive cataloguing and subject\ud cataloguing, noting the nature of the errors and their results. The investigation\ud concludes that intelligence alone does not guarantee library ability, and that\ud cataloguing beyond the creation of minimum records is not an intuitive task to be\ud picked up without training. Hidden expenses are attached. A derisory attitude\ud towards library skills is unjustified, and a place remains for qualified librarians to do qualified library work.Pre-print of article published in Journal of Librarianship and Information Science,\ud 38(3) (Sept. 2006), 173-85.