Penetrating localities: participatory development and pragmatic politics in rural Andhra Pradesh, India

Doctoral thesis English OPEN
Powis, Benjamin (2012)
  • Subject: DS401 | HD0072

This research sets out to explore the interface between the new politics of localisation and the political process in India. Governments and donors have increasingly emphasised the locality as the primary unit of development and politics. This new trajectory has been manifest in the increase of community-based organisations and mechanisms of participatory governance at the local level. From the late 1990s, the south Indian state of Andhra Pradesh emerged as one of the most important examples of this new developmental politics and this research sets out to explore how local dynamics changed as a result. \ud \ud Political economy approaches tend to focus on state-periphery relations in terms of interest groups or vote banks. By contrast, this research found the village to be an enduring unit in the political system through which political identity manifests itself through three features. First, participation in local elections is driven by common forces of politics of parties, caste and corruption but its outcome is dependent on the specific context at the village level. Second, new participatory institutions created through state policy were found to merge with informal practices at the local level and produce a complex interplay between the new local and state identities. Third, analysis of leadership found evidence of a well-defined system of organisation within party groups at the village level, which were shaped not by party institutions but by the inner workings of village politics. \ud \ud These findings give cause to reassess the way in which we understand policy and political change. I do so by expanding on Skocpol's polity approach, which focused attention on the dynamic interplay of policy and social structure. Drawing on elements of the 'political development' theory, the concept of a ‘developing polity’ approach is elaborated on, to better explain the complex interplay between local and higher level politics. These findings have implications for understanding both political change in India and development strategy. The macro-perspective on the decay of political institutions is contrasted with a local perspective that finds evidence of the vitality of party politics at the village level. This has a number of important implications for development, both in terms of the way in which we analyse participation and the way in which participatory development can be translated into political change
  • References (7)

    Weiner, M. (1962) 'Political Parties and Panchayati Raj' in Indian Journal of Public Administration VIII(4): 623-28.

    Weiner, M. (1965) 'India: Two Political Cultures. Political Culture and Political Development' in L. W. Pye and S. Verba. (eds), Political Culture and Political Development, Princeton: Princeton University Press pp 199-244

    Weiner, M. (1967). Party Building in a New Nation, University of Chicago Press.

    Whitehead and Molina (1999) 'The Long Term Politics of Pro-Poor Policies' Conference Paper, Prepared for the “World Development Report 2000/1: The Responsiveness of Political Systems to Poverty Reduction”, Donnington Castle, 16-17 August, 1999

    Williams, G et al (2011) 'Performing Participatory Citizenship - Politics and Power in Kerala's Kudumbashree Programme', in The Journal of Development Studies, Volume 47, Issue 8, pp. 1261 - 1280

    Williams, G. (2001) 'Understanding “political stability”: party action and political discourse in West Bengal', in Third World Quarterly 22 (4) 603-622

    World Bank (2000) Overview of Rural Decentralization in India - Volume 2, unpublished Report, World Bank Washington D.C.

  • Metrics
    No metrics available
Share - Bookmark