Measuring what matters in specialist domestic violence courts

Book English OPEN
Robinson, Amanda L. ; Cardiff University (2008)
  • Publisher: Cardiff University
  • Subject: K1 | H1 | HV

Using data from seven specialist domestic violence courts (SDVCs) in England and\ud Wales, it is argued that these relatively new institutions need to re-orient themselves\ud away from typical criminal justice performance measures (such as arrests,\ud prosecutions and convictions) and towards measuring what matters to the service\ud users themselves (in this case, victims of domestic violence). Analysis of 438 cases\ud revealed substantial variability in the case progression practices across the seven\ud SDVCs. Sentencing outcomes also were significantly different by court location,\ud despite hearing similar types of cases. Together with victim interview data, these\ud findings suggest that traditional performance indicators cannot tell us much about the\ud performance of SDVCs, in part because ‘success’ in a domestic violence case is\ud difficult to define using criminal justice terms alone. An alternative approach\ud involving the measurement of ‘quality prosecution’ and ‘quality sentencing’ is offered\ud which could not only provide a more meaningful assessment of a court’s\ud performance, but also could more accurately represent ‘what matters’ to victims of\ud domestic violence.
  • References (1)

    A Sanders, 'Personal violence and public order: The prosecution of “domestic” violence in England and Wales' (1988) 16 International Journal of the Sociology of Law 359

  • Metrics
    0
    views in OpenAIRE
    0
    views in local repository
    58
    downloads in local repository

    The information is available from the following content providers:

    From Number Of Views Number Of Downloads
    Online Research @ Cardiff - IRUS-UK 0 58
Share - Bookmark